Category: Money

  • How states and great powers typically deal with high debt

    Historically, there are only four real paths. It’s always about shifting losses — the question is who pays.

    1. Growth (the cleanest, but hardest)

    • The economy grows faster than debt
    • Debt shrinks relative to GDP
    • Rare, requires productivity, innovation, stability

    Examples: USA after WWII, Germany after 1950

    Reality: today almost impossible without additional tools

    2. Inflation (the most commonly used)

    • Debt stays the same in nominal terms
    • Purchasing power falls → debt is “inflated away”
    • A hidden tax on savers and the middle class

    Used when:

    • debt is in the domestic currency
    • the central bank cooperates with the state

    Examples:
    1970s USA, post-war Europe, today’s USA/EU

    Inflation is politically the least painful — people don’t understand it immediately.

    3. Financial repression

    • Artificially low interest rates
    • Forced purchases of government bonds (banks, funds)
    • Capital controls, regulations, taxes, withdrawal limits

    Effect:
    negative real yields → creditors pay debtors

    Examples:
    USA 1945–1980, Japan long-term, EU indirectly

    4. Default / restructuring

    • Partial debt write-offs
    • Extended maturities
    • Lower interest rates

    Used when denial is no longer possible

    Examples:
    Greece 2012, Argentina repeatedly, Russia 1998

    5. War (an extreme reset)

    • Physical destruction = economic reset
    • Debts erased via inflation, default, or a new order

    Historically common, politically unpopular today — but not impossible

    How high household debt is dealt with

    Households have fewer options than states. Typical scenarios:

    A. Inflation + wages (soft scenario)

    • Real wages rise
    • Debts remain nominally the same
    • Installments “hurt less”

    Works only if:

    • loans have fixed interest rates
    • incomes grow at least as fast as inflation

    B. Refinancing / extending maturities

    • Longer repayment periods
    • Lower monthly payments
    • Higher total interest paid

    Very common
    Politically safe

    C. Bankruptcy / personal debt relief

    • Part of the debt written off
    • Loss of assets and credit score
    • Social and psychological costs

    Used en masse during crises
    USA 2008–2012

    D. Selling assets

    • Real estate, investments
    • Reduced consumption
    • Economy-wide deleveraging

    Leads to crises
    (deflationary pressure)

    E. Moral hazard (politics)

    • State rescues debtors
    • Partial debt forgiveness
    • Losses transferred to taxpayers

    Examples:
    mortgage moratoria, COVID measures

    Summary

    Debts are never resolved without pain.
    The pain is only shifted.

    • Inflation → savers
    • Taxes → workers
    • Default → creditors
    • Recession → employees
    • Financial repression → pension funds